Finding the right toaster can make busy mornings run a whole lot smoother and even add a little joy to the breakfast rush. I have tested my fair share of toasters in our kitchen and know how important it is to have one that toasts evenly, fits your favorite breads, and is easy to clean up after the kids have made their own snacks.
Below you will find my top picks from trusted brands like BELLA, BLACK+DECKER, and Cuisinart, including models that work beautifully for everything from thick bagels to homemade sourdough.
Top picks
Comparison table
| Product |
Color |
Material |
Wattage |
Number of Slices |
Number of Shade Settings |
Link |
| BELLA 2 Slice Slim Toaster |
Oatmilk |
Plastic, Stainless Steel |
900 watts |
2 |
3 |
Get Price |
| Cuisinart 2-Slice XL Slot Toaster |
— |
— |
— |
2 |
7 |
Get Price |
| BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster |
Black |
Aluminum |
1400 watts |
4 |
7 |
Get Price |
| BELLA 2 Slice Slim Toaster |
Surf |
Plastic, Stainless Steel |
900 watts |
2 |
3 |
Get Price |
01
BELLA 2 Slice Slim Toaster
BELLA
Main highlights
- Capacity: 2 slices
- Slot length: 10 inches
- Power: 900 watts
- Settings: 6 shade levels
- Removable crumb tray
Pros
- Slim profile saves counter space
- Long slot fits larger or artisan breads
- Multiple shade settings and reheat function
Cons
- Only two slices at a time
- Plastic build may feel less premium
- Lower wattage than some competitors
Size
This toaster is slim and lightweight. It measures under 15 inches wide and less than 4 inches deep. It fits easily on crowded countertops.
Look
The design is modern with a neutral Oatmilk color. Plastic and stainless steel materials give it a simple appearance. It is available in several color options.
Function
It offers six shade settings plus reheat and cancel buttons. The long slot accommodates wide or long bread slices. Features include auto shutoff, anti jam, and a removable crumb tray.
Summary
This model is best for those with limited space who want flexibility for different bread types. It is less powerful and has fewer features than some higher priced toasters but is affordable and easy to use.
Show less
02
Cuisinart 2-Slice XL Slot Toaster
Cuisinart
Main highlights
- Slots: Extra large
- Shade settings: 7
- Functions: Bagel, Defrost, Single Slice, +30 Seconds, Cancel
Pros
- Fits longer and thicker bread
- Multiple shade and function options
- Easy to clean with removable tray
Cons
- Only two slots
- No digital display
- Bulkier than compact models
Size
This toaster is larger than standard two slice models. The extra large slots accommodate longer and thicker bread. It may take up more counter space than compact options.
Look
The design is simple and neutral. The stone color blends with most kitchen styles. Controls are clearly labeled and easy to access.
Function
It offers seven shade settings and several function buttons. The high lift lever makes it easy to check toast. The removable crumb tray helps with cleaning.
Summary
This model is a good choice for those who often toast artisanal or homemade bread. It is more versatile than basic toasters but less advanced than high end models with digital features.
Show less
03
BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster
BLACK+DECKER
Main highlights
- Capacity: 4 slices
- Power: 1400 watts
- Shade settings: 7
- Functions: Bagel, Frozen, Cancel
- Dimensions: 11.1 x 10.67 x 6.89 inches
Pros
- Wide slots fit thick bread and bagels
- Seven shade settings for customization
- Easy to clean with removable crumb tray
Cons
- Bulkier than two slice models
- No digital display
- Plastic exterior may feel less premium
Size
This toaster is larger than most two slice models. It can handle four slices at once, making it suitable for families or shared kitchens.
Look
The black and silver finish gives it a simple and modern appearance. The plastic exterior is lightweight but may not match the look of stainless steel competitors.
Function
It offers wide slots for bagels and thick bread. There are dedicated buttons for bagels and frozen items. The seven shade settings allow for a range of browning preferences. The crumb tray helps with easy cleaning.
Summary
Compared to other four slice toasters, this model provides reliable performance and basic features at a moderate price. It lacks advanced options like digital controls but covers most daily needs.
Show less
04
BELLA 2 Slice Slim Toaster
BELLA
Main highlights
- Capacity: 2 slices
- Slot length: 10 inches
- Power: 900 watts
- Shade settings: 6
- Removable crumb tray
Pros
- Slim profile saves counter space
- Long slot fits larger or artisan breads
- Multiple shade settings
Cons
- Only two slices at a time
- Plastic exterior may feel less premium
- Lower wattage than some competitors
Size
This toaster is slim and lightweight. It measures just under 15 inches wide and less than 4 inches deep. It is easy to fit on crowded countertops.
Look
The design is modern with a plastic and stainless steel finish. The Surf color adds a pop of style. It is available in several other colors.
Function
It toasts two slices at once with a single long slot. There are six shade settings plus reheat and cancel buttons. Features include auto shutoff, anti jam, and a removable crumb tray.
Summary
This model is best for users who want a compact toaster that can handle longer or wider bread. It is less powerful than some pricier options but offers good value for basic toasting tasks.
Show less
Final verdict
If you are looking for a new toaster, there are some great options to consider. For those on a budget, the BELLA 2 Slice Slim Toaster stands out for its compact design and reliable performance at an affordable price. If you want the best value, the Cuisinart 2-Slice XL Slot Toaster offers extra wide slots and consistent toasting results, making it a smart choice for most kitchens.
Overall, both of these toasters deliver solid performance and convenience. Whether you prioritize saving money or getting the most features for your investment, you will find a dependable pick among these top choices.
FAQs
What makes the bella 2-Slice Slim Toaster stand out for small kitchens
Its slim 3.58 inch profile saves space while still offering a long slot for versatile toasting.
Can these toasters handle thick or long breads
Yes the extra wide and long slots fit artisan breads bagels and even Texas toast without cutting or squeezing.
How many shade settings do these toasters offer
Models reviewed offer between six and seven shade settings for precise browning control.
Is it easy to clean these toasters
Yes all reviewed models have removable crumb trays for quick cleanup and some include cord storage to reduce clutter.
How do I safely remove small items like English muffins
Use the high lift lever feature which raises smaller slices for easy and safe removal.
Do these toasters have special functions for bagels or frozen items
Yes most models include dedicated bagel and frozen buttons for optimal results.
What is the average customer rating for these toasters
The reviewed toasters have ratings between 4.3 and 4.4 stars.
