Finding the best ice cream maker can transform your kitchen into a personal ice cream parlor. With options from a mix of brands and models, there’s a machine to suit every preference and budget. This guide covers a variety of choices across mixed price tiers, helping you compare features and value. Whether you’re a novice or an enthusiast, our recommendations aim to simplify your search and ensure delicious results.
Top Picks
- Best compact: Whynter 1.28 Qt Upright Compressor — read more
- Best smart features: Ninja CREAMi Deluxe XL — read more
- Best premium: Whynter 2.1 Qt Compressor — read more
- Best large rooms: Elite Gourmet 6 Qt Vintage Bucket — read more
- Best value: Ninja CREAMi 7-in-1 — read more
Comparison Table
| Product | Capacity | Material | Dimensions | Weight | Operation Mode | Special Features | Included Components | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whynter 1.28 Qt Upright Compressor | 1.28 Quarts | Plastic | 13.8"L x 9.8"W x 13.8"H | 19.25 pounds | Automatic | Built-In Timer, Motor Protection Function | Removable stainless bowl and BPA free churn blade for effortless cleaning | Get Price |
| Ninja CREAMi Deluxe XL | 1.5 Pounds | Metal | 12.01"L x 8.42"W x 16.69"H | – | Automatic | Customization, Dual Drive Motor, Large Capacity | Motor Base, Deluxe Creamerizer Paddle, (4) 24 oz. XL Tubs with Lids, Outer Bowl, Recipe Guide | Get Price |
| Whynter 2.1 Qt Compressor | 2.1 Quarts | Stainless Steel | 16.75"L x 11.25"W x 10.25"H | 24.2 pounds | Automatic | Motor Protection Function, Audible Timer | BPA-free aluminum removable mixing bowl and churn blade | Get Price |
| Elite Gourmet 6 Qt Vintage Bucket | 6 Quarts | Wood | 15 x 12 x 21.5 inches | 14.3 pounds | Automatic | Programmable | Ice cream maker | Get Price |
| Ninja CREAMi 7-in-1 | 3.8 Pounds | – | – | – | Automatic | 7 One-Touch Programs, Customization | Bowl, Cup, Ice cream machine, Lid | Get Price |
Whynter 1.28 Qt Upright Compressor
Pros
- No pre-freezing required—built-in compressor
- Continuous batch capability
- Compact, upright design saves space
- Easy-to-use LCD controls
Cons
- Smaller capacity than some competitors
- Heavier than non-compressor models
- Higher price point for the size
Size
The Whynter ICM-128WS is compact and upright, making it suitable for kitchens with limited counter space. Its 1.28-quart capacity is smaller than some alternatives, but sufficient for small households.
Function
This model features a built-in compressor, eliminating the need to pre-freeze bowls. It allows for back-to-back batches and has an extended cooling function to prevent melting.
Look
The white finish and modern LCD panel give it a clean, contemporary appearance. The removable stainless bowl and BPA-free churn blade make cleaning straightforward.
Summary
Compared to other compact ice cream makers, the Whynter stands out for its self-cooling technology and ease of use. While pricier and heavier than basic models, it offers convenience and reliability for frequent homemade frozen treats.
Ninja CREAMi Deluxe XL
Pros
- XL 24 oz. tubs—50% more than standard models
- 11 treat programs for wide variety
- Customizable for dietary needs
- Includes four storage tubs
Cons
- Noticeably loud during operation
- Only compatible with NC500 series tubs
- Requires overnight freezing
Size
The Ninja CREAMi Deluxe XL features a larger footprint and taller build than many home ice cream makers. Its 24 oz. tubs provide more servings per batch—ideal for families or gatherings.
Function
With 11 preset programs, this model handles ice cream, sorbet, milkshakes, frozen yogurt, and more. The dual-drive motor and re-spin function allow for texture control and mix-in customization.
Look
Finished in stone silver, the unit has a modern appearance. The included tubs and accessories are designed for easy storage and cleaning.
Summary
Compared to similar machines, the Ninja CREAMi Deluxe XL excels in capacity and versatility. It is louder than most, but offers more treat options and customization for dietary preferences.
Whynter 2.1 Qt Compressor
Pros
- No pre-freezing required
- Large 2.1 qt capacity
- Stainless steel build
- Extended cooling and motor protection
Cons
- Heavy and bulky
- Higher price than basic models
Size
This unit is larger and heavier than most entry-level ice cream makers—plan for countertop space. The 2.1 quart capacity is above average, allowing for bigger batches.
Look
Features a modern stainless steel finish and a clear LCD control panel. The design is more refined than many plastic competitors.
Function
Built-in compressor means no pre-freezing—start making ice cream anytime. Extended cooling and motor protection functions add convenience and safety.
Summary
Compared to peers, this model offers more capacity and automation. It costs more than basic models but delivers consistent results and ease of use for frequent homemade ice cream.
Elite Gourmet 6 Qt Vintage Bucket
Pros
- High 6-quart capacity—ideal for groups
- Dual operation: electric motor or hand crank
- Classic wood bucket aesthetic
- Easy to clean aluminum canister
Cons
- Takes up more space than compact models
- Requires ice and rock salt for operation
- Heavier than plastic alternatives
Size
This model offers a generous 6-quart capacity—larger than most home ice cream makers. Its tall, sturdy build makes it suitable for parties but less ideal for small kitchens.
Look
Features a vintage Appalachian wood bucket. The classic design stands out compared to plastic or metal competitors.
Function
Can be used with an electric motor or hand crank. Requires ice and rock salt, which is traditional but less convenient than compressor-based models.
Summary
Best for those seeking a nostalgic experience and serving larger groups. Bulky size and manual steps may not suit everyone, but performance is strong for its category.
Ninja CREAMi 7-in-1
Pros
- Multiple dessert options—ice cream, gelato, sorbet, and more
- Simple one-touch programs
- Includes five pints for storage and serving
- Customizable for dietary needs
Cons
- Requires overnight freezing of base
- Limited to compatible Ninja models
- Moderate noise during operation
Function
Offers seven preset programs for a range of frozen desserts—ice cream, gelato, smoothie bowls, and more. One-touch operation simplifies the process. Mix-in feature allows for added customization.
Size
Compact footprint compared to traditional compressor ice cream makers. Five included pints support batch preparation and storage.
Comparison
Unlike many value-segment ice cream makers, this model does not require a pre-frozen bowl but does need the base to be frozen overnight. More versatile than basic models—peers often lack smoothie bowl or mix-in options.
Summary
A strong choice for families or anyone seeking variety and convenience in homemade frozen treats. Best for those who value customization and easy cleanup.
Final Verdict
For the best ice cream maker, the Whynter 1.28 Qt Upright Compressor stands out as the top choice for those seeking a compact, efficient, and user-friendly machine that consistently delivers creamy results. Its upright design saves space without sacrificing performance, making it ideal for smaller kitchens or frequent use.
If you are looking for advanced features and versatility, the Ninja CREAMi Deluxe XL impresses with its smart controls and multiple settings that allow you to create everything from ice cream to sorbet and milkshakes with ease. Both options cater to different needs but guarantee delicious homemade frozen treats every time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which ice cream maker is best for making multiple batches quickly
The Whynter 2.1 Qt Compressor is ideal for making multiple batches due to its larger capacity and compressor technology
Are Ninja CREAMi models easy to use and clean
Yes both the Ninja CREAMi Deluxe XL and 7-in-1 models are praised for user friendly controls and easy cleaning
Which model offers the best value for families
The Elite Gourmet 6 Qt Vintage Bucket offers great value for families with its large capacity and affordable price
How durable are Whynter ice cream makers
Whynter models are known for their sturdy build and reliable performance with many users reporting long term durability
What features set the Ninja CREAMi Deluxe XL apart
The Ninja CREAMi Deluxe XL offers extra functions like mix ins and customizable textures making it versatile for different frozen treats
Do these ice cream makers have good customer ratings
Yes all reviewed models have ratings between 4.4 and 4.7 stars with positive feedback on performance and features
Is there a compact option for smaller kitchens
The Whynter 1.28 Qt Upright Compressor is compact and suitable for kitchens with limited space
